Have they both actually been fully evaluated by each service or did some of them just see they had offers and assign them 2 stars sight unseen? I would be pretty surprised if Hernandez at least was not re-evaluated during his senior season.
Nance may have some trouble with the recruiting services with him being over at Gulfport CC Juco.
Oddly enough it looks like rivals has moved nance to a three star since I posted my original question…
I was looking and can’t tell on my phone (yeah mobile platforms :-/) because either rivals or scout (they both had him as a two at the time) was still showing him as committed to GATech (I think it was them) so I knew that that had not been updated since 2014.